Talking across the curriculum (using Good idea / Bad idea)

Planning talk structures into your lessons is important if you want to help your pupils learn through talk.

One structure is Good Idea / Bad Idea. Look out for opportunities where you can use this to engage pupils and get them thinking in different subjects. For example:

Forest path with bright sunlight and wildflowers.
  • Wandering through a forest – good idea / bad idea? (English – Goldilocks)

  • Eating only seasonal fruit & veg – good idea / bad idea? (DT – Cooking)

  • Living in the Stone Age – good idea / bad idea? (History)

  • Being an explorer – good idea / bad idea? (Geography)

  • Always using column subtraction – good idea / bad idea? (Maths)

  • Genetic modification – good idea / bad idea? (Science)

Remember that the point is to ask an opinion or thinking question, which any pupil could respond to. (It should not be a question which has a correct answer.)